I want to make my boyfriend something homemade for Valentine's Day, but I don't know if he'll like it.?

I want to give him something that's meaningful and not just "taken off the shelf". I'm really good at making homemade stuff but I'm afraid he'll hate those kind of gifts and think they're like "girly" or "stupid" or something (example- crocheting, knitting, sewing, woodcraft, etc...all my areas). If I was to make him something like that, what could I possibly make him that he would even remotely like?...and I'm not cheap at all!!! I'm going to buy him something too (what exactly...I don't know at the moment), but I just think it means more if it comes from the heart...